PYMATUNING PIZZA

Custom Pizza Orders

Fresh pizzas made to order with your choice of toppings and generous portions.

• Meat lovers specialty available
• Extra cheese portions included
• Custom topping combinations

Hoagie Shop

Fresh submarine sandwiches prepared with quality meats and fresh vegetables.

• Multiple meat and veggie options
• Fresh bread daily
• Custom combinations available

Takeout Service

Quick pickup service for busy families and lake visitors.

• 20-minute average wait time
• Call-ahead ordering recommended
• Carry-out assistance available

Online Ordering

Digital ordering through third-party platforms, though direct calling is recommended.

• Slice platform integration
• Direct phone orders preferred
• Payment processing available

“REALLY GOOD! Really busy day and coming back home and I didn't want to cook, so I stopped. Now mind this, I am not a pizza fan. We got a meat lovers and added black olives and banana peppers and it was ready in about 20 minutes. Picked up and went out to the car and got a good smell of the pie inside and it smelled great and when we got it home, the taste was better than it smelled. The new owners have been there a couple months and I wish them well..and what a great pizza pie!”

“Great pizza & hoagies! Friendly service & helped me to the car with my order!!”

“My first time getting pizza here. I ordered and paid through the Slice website which gave me a 45 minute wait time. Arrived at that time and was told that Slice wasn't working and they did not have my order. They apologized profusely and said they would make my order but I would have to wait another 15 minutes. When my order was finished they added an order of cheesy breadsticks for my inconvenience. The pizza was good but be careful ordering extra cheese unless you want EXTRA cheese. I'm not sure if that's normal or they were still trying to make up for the problems with the website. This is definitely a place I would go back to. The workers recommended the shop directly next time.”

“Updated : I have been back and the pizza was delicious, it has a good taste will stop back again . I talked to the owner and I'm sorry it took me this long to get back I'm sad to say my first experience here was bad. I went in and ordered, paid , and said my order would be ready in a half hour . I returned and they never made my pizza, I got my money back , but it was too late for us to go anywhere else . I hope if I come back it is a better”